Editor’s Note: Brian Frank manages private wealth and a mid cap value mutual fund Frank Value Fund (FNKIX).
Money-transfer company Western Union (WU) got its start in the telegram business during the 1800s. Now, several hundred years later, Western Union specializes in the money remittance market, helping people living in a new country send money to family back home, wherever on the globe that may be.
When remittances utilized paper money, Western Union dominated the business. However, as remittances moved to electronic transfer, Western Union suffered with its large infrastructure built for cash, causing it to lag well-funded competition in the online market. Now, with a relatively new CEO and a critical mass of online business, I believe Western Union is at an inflection point in its business and will outgrow market expectations in the next few years.
Lowering the Bar
Currently trading at <6x 2024 estimated EV/EBITDA, with an 8% FCF/EV yield, and a 8.0% dividend yield, Western Union has an undemanding valuation. The market is valuing the company as a melting ice cube, or a business that is in slow, terminal decline. Instead, I believe Western Union can grow its earnings at a mid-single digit rate in the next few years. When valuation is low enough, even a slightly better than expected business performance can result in large stock upside.
Industry Upturn
Consider this chart from Western Union’s Q1 2024 Investor Presentation:
New CEO’s Initiatives
CEO Devin McGranahan arrived in December 2021 from Fiserv. McGranahan is focused on seemingly obvious initiatives that previous management failed to prioritize: agent quality and profitability (instead of growth at any cost), incentivizing in-person agents to promote digital transactions (instead of fighting the trend towards digital), locking in returning customers, and monetizing the receiving side of the network.
fter about 18 months of McGranahan’s leadership, the company is at a fundamental turning point. The spread between digital transaction and revenue growth is improving, with a 300bps improvement in Q1 2024. Branded digital business is growing at 9% which is the highest growth since COVID bump in Q3 2021.
Western Union has about $3b of retail revenue and $1b of digital. Management’s stated goal at Investor Day is to get the retail business to stable revenue, and the double-digit growth on digital means company-wide top-line will grow mid-single digits. With analysts expecting flat growth in 2025, believing management is clearly a variant perception. McGranahan is delivering on his agenda but the market has yet to give him any credit.
Aligning agents with higher return on capital goals is a no-brainer that should have been done a decade ago. The company previously used large sign-on bonuses for agents and has since transitioned to performance-oriented contracts. This change will positively affect Western Union’s agent acquisition cost globally while reducing agent churn costs. This approach also weeds out bad-actor agents who churn sign-on bonuses. Quality agents agree to performance incentives because they can make more money.
Everybody wins. Management recently disclosed 90% agent productivity with a goal towards 100%. Unprofitable agents will be forced to leave the network and Western Union salespeople are only paid on productivity thresholds. Fixing incentive leaks will help management achieve its stated goal of sustainable, profitable revenue growth by 2025.
Monetizing the receiving side of the network with debit cards generating interchange fees is a potential source of $300-400mm of revenue according to management. Western Union focused marketing exclusively on the sender in the past, but they have realized that 40% of receivers decide which money transfer provider to use. Rather than finishing the transaction at the receiver, debit cards will keep the money in network at very little additional cost.
Simple features like “Quick Resend” and “Remember Me” ease customer friction by pre-populating Know Your Customer forms for returning customers. This also increases customer lock-in. The average retail transaction pre-McGranahan was 7 minutes and can now be done in 3 clicks with Quick Resend. For the 80% of transactions that are repeat transactions this is a major upgrade. The company is still rolling out these initiatives that will improve profitability and revenue retention.
More transactions, more products and services, and higher retention rates will raise the customer lifetime values and stabilize the retail business. All of these actions require little capital but generate high returns.
Branded Digital Profitability Inflection
Branded Digital revenue growth was 9% in Q1 2024 with 13% transaction growth. The spread between the two is 400 basis points compared to double-digits in Q1 2023. Management expects to exit 2024 around 400 basis points indicating a stabilization of pricing. This has been a top priority of management and the trend indicates a successful turn. Here are the last six quarters of FX neutral Branded Digital YoY revenue growth:
Q2 2024: +7%
Q1 2024: +9%
Q4 2023: +4%
Q3 2023: +3%
Q2 2023: -2%
Q1 2023: -6%
Branded digital is clearly growing, and Q1’s 9% was the highest growth rate since Q3 2021. Changing company culture has been a battle:
March 14, 2024 Wolfe Research FinTech Forum
“We talked a lot about returning the digital business to double-digit transaction and revenue growth. And starting in the second quarter of — or in the fourth quarter of ’22, we laid out the formula, grow new customers double digits. That will lead to double-digit transaction growth, which will lead to double-digit revenue growth. We announced double-digit new customer growth fourth quarter of ’22. We announced double-digit transaction growth second quarter of ’23, and in the fourth quarter, we (had) revenue growth of 4% in the digital business and starting to close that gap, so that has almost gone formulaically like we had laid out and hoped.”
“And so we expect to see progression quarter-over-quarter of the narrowing of that gap between transactions and revenue for our digital business. Changing the hearts and minds of 10,000 people to have a very customer-first mindset is still work in progress.”
Western Union CEO Devin McGranahan
Shareholder Friendly
Western Union’s stock repurchases failed to keep most long-term investors from suffering losses because revenue has been declining. However, for a company returning to growth yet still trading at a low valuation, repurchases become accretive. Total shares outstanding have declined 4% in 2023 and 5% in 2022. There is $198mm remaining on the 2024 authorization which is 4% of shares outstanding at this price, and adding that to a 8% sustainable dividend (50% payout ratio), you get a 12% yield to shareholders.
Management has repurchased over $300mm of stock per year from 2021-2024, and if this continues, the forward repurchase yield is around 7%. Add that to a 8% dividend and you have one of the highest shareholder yields in the market while enjoying an inflection towards growth. High, sustainable dividends and large stock repurchases at attractive valuations are catalysts the Frank Value Fund focuses on to realize returns. Western Union is one of the more attractive opportunities in the fund today.
Conclusion
In a return-to-growth scenario, I believe Western Union should be valued at 10-12x EBITDA. If the company can grow with global GDP, target is 9x 2025 EV/EBITDA or $22 per share which implies 85% upside before dividends. Thanks for reading!
Brian Frank
CIO Frank Capital Partners LLC
A new, secretive move being carried out by the Fed that has nothing to do with lowering or raising interest rates... could soon have an enormous impact on your wealth. According to Dan Ferris, the banking expert who once predicted the collapse of Lehman Brothers, "Millions are about to be blindsided." More here.
Source: Frank Funds
